Welcome to the Skeptical Investor Newsletter. A frank, hopefully insightful, dive into real estate and financial markets. From one real estate investor to another.
This week, we’re talkin’ the real cost of operating a rental (it’s more than most renters can afford to pay), the quiet turn in national rents, Nashville’s job machine, and an indoor golf course the size of three Walmarts.
Let’s get into it.
Today’s Interest Rate: 6.81%
(☝️ .04% from this time last week, 30-yr mortgage)
Rates hit a three-week high Friday after the new Fed Chair’s Jackson Hole speech spooked the bond market: the 10-year Treasury pushed up to 4.71%, long yields are grinding higher, and bonds appear to be pricing in more inflation risk. It’s starting to get a little weird again.
More on what that actually means for us below.
The Weekly 3 in News:
Mortgage rates jumped to three-week highs after Jackson Hole gathering. Fed Chair Kevin Warsh used his first Jackson Hole keynote to voice concern about current inflation trends, and bonds sold off hard: the 30-year fixed rose to 6.81% and the 10-year Treasury hit 4.71%. (Mortgage News Daily, Aug 28)
Inflation’s last mile is stalled. Core PCE, the Fed’s preferred inflation gauge, held at 3.3% year-over-year in July; headline held at 3.7%. Personal income rose 0.4% and spending rose 0.2% on the month. (BEA, Aug 29). We need more progress on inflation (oil prices) for mortgage rates to come down.
The economy still looks hot. The Atlanta Fed’s GDPNow tracker estimates Q3 growth at 4.6% as of August 26, up from 4.0% earlier in the month. Whatever consumers say in surveys, the spending data isn’t cooperating with the doom narrative. (Atlanta Fed GDPNow)
Fun Things Happening in Nashville This Week:
America’s first full 18-hole indoor golf course is coming to Nashville! CityGolf USA is building it inside a 174,000-square-foot building. High-tech simulators, real putting surfaces, an indoor driving range, a chefy restaurant, and PGA pros on staff. Opening this winter, and Nashville is the first of several planned US locations. (NewsChannel 5). Landlords near Centennial Blvd, your foot traffic may be about to change.
Nashville Dance Fest, Vol. 4 takes over 90,000+ square feet at the Nashville Palace, Sept 4–6: five tented dance floors, honky-tonk competitions, live acts all weekend. Launch party Thursday Sept 3 at Category 10. (Visit Music City)
Lee Brice, Gabby Barrett and Payton Smith play the Music City Kickoff Concert at Ascend Amphitheater, Saturday Sept 5, 7pm. Big outdoor country bill on the river for the holiday weekend. (Ascend Amphitheater)
The $600 Tenant Problem
Hat tip to housing economist Jay Parsons for laying this one out.
Think rents are too expensive? Landlords have to raise rents to cover operating expense inflation.
A not so fun fact: nearly one-third of American renters can’t afford to cover the landlord’s operating costs of a typical rental unit. Not the rent. Not the landlord’s profit. The operating costs: taxes, insurance, maintenance, utilities, payroll. The cost of keeping the lights on and the roof from leaking.
Here’s the math, from Parsons:
1)) Around 30% of American renters make less than $30,000 a year. More than a million of those renters earn $0.
2)) For rent plus utilities to be considered “affordable,” it shouldn’t eat more than 30% of income.
3)) That means rent plus utilities must come in below $600 a month, and that’s at the top of that income band.
4)) Ask any property manager: operating costs for apartments and single-family rentals usually run well above $600 a month, even for older, less-amenitized properties. Older buildings tend to have higher maintenance costs, not lower.

The national data backs him up. The National Apartment Association’s survey of over a million units put average operating expenses at $8,657 per unit in 2024. That’s $721 a month. Before the mortgage. Before a dollar of return. Taxes are typically the biggest single line item, roughly a quarter of the total.
$721 to operate. $600 affordable ceiling for a third of the renter population.

You can’t discount your way around that. The building doesn’t care.
Speak naturally. Send without fixing.
Wispr Flow turns your voice into clean, professional text you can send the moment you stop talking. Not rough transcription you have to clean up. Actual polished text — ready for email, Slack, or any app.
Speak the way you think. Go on tangents. Change your mind mid-sentence. Flow strips the filler, fixes the grammar, and gives you text that reads like you spent five minutes writing it.
89% of messages sent with zero edits. Millions of professionals use Flow daily, including teams at OpenAI, Vercel, and Clay. Works on Mac, Windows, and iPhone.
Why Costs Exploded
Now connect this to the inflation number in the Weekly 3. Core PCE stuck at 3.3% isn’t an abstraction: it lives in every line of your operating statement, and it has been compounding for five years.
Insurance: multifamily property insurance premiums in 2024 were roughly double 2021 levels, six times the CPI increase over the same period. The yearly increases stack: +14%, then +22%, then +45%. (National Apartment Association) The Fed’s own researchers measured real per-unit insurance costs going from about $465 in 2019 to about $821 in 2024. (Federal Reserve)

Source: NAA Premium Pulse; index compounded from stated yearly increases.
Construction and materials: construction input prices are up roughly 43% since February 2020. Iron and steel up 56%, concrete up 28%, lumber up 29%. (Associated Builders and Contractors) Every roof, every water heater, every turn costs more than it did when your pro forma was written.
Repairs and maintenance: up more than 28% since 2021, running about $1,098 per unit per year. (NAA data via Lula)

Sources: NAA; Associated Builders & Contractors/BLS; NAA via Lula. Baselines differ as labeled.
Key Takeaway: when someone says “the rent is too high,” the more precise statement may be “the cost of operating housing is too high, and incomes at the bottom third are too low.” Those are different problems with different solutions. If the narrative only ever talks about rent, nothing anyone does (short of vouchers and subsidies like LIHTC, the low-income housing tax credit) will make rentals affordable for a third of American renters.
This is also, frankly, why operators who survive are the ones who obsess over the expense side. Cash flow is the first of the five ways real estate builds wealth, and it’s the one you control most directly: I wrote a whole book about those five engines, and the expense line is where most of them get won or lost. One practical example from my own units: water damage drives a huge share of insurance claims, and insurance is the fastest-growing line on the statement. A pack of smart leak sensors under the water heaters and washing machines is about the cheapest premium protection you can buy.
Rents Just Turned. Quietly.
Speaking of rents…
The national median rose to $1,390 in August, up 0.1% from July: the seventh straight monthly increase, and the first positive August since 2022. (Apartment List; CNBC)
Year-over-year, rents are still down 0.8%, but that gap has been narrowing for months (it was −1.1% in July). One month is noise. Seven months in the same direction is a trend, cue the NBA Jam rule.
Regular Skeptical Investors readers saw this coming. I called the supply turn in the Apartment Glut Is Going Keto article back in July, and went deep on the disappearing construction pipeline last week. This week we confirmed it.
The Pipeline Is Emptying, Fast
Three numbers tell the supply story:
1)) Deliveries are falling off a cliff. New apartment deliveries went from 695,000 units in 2024 to 531,000 in 2025, and are projected at just 382,000 for 2026, a 28% drop. 2027 is forecast to fall another 24%, which pencils to roughly 290,000 units. (Apartments.com/CoStar)

Source: Apartments.com/CoStar 2026 supply outlook; 2027 calculated from stated −24%.
2)) Under-construction counts have collapsed. Roughly 579,000 units were under construction in Q1 2026, down more than 50% from the early-2023 peak above one million. (CoStar via Multifamily Dive)

Source: CoStar.
3)) Starts have basically stopped. About 55,000 multifamily units broke ground in Q1 2026, down 73% from the early-2022 peak and the lowest quarterly figure since 2011. (CoStar) RealPage counted just 75,205 completions in Q1 2026, the lightest quarter in four years. (RealPage)

Source: CoStar; peak implied from stated −73%.
Apartments take roughly two years to build. The units not started in 2025 and 2026 are the units that can’t deliver in 2027 and 2028. This locks in a supply hole, no matter what happens to rates. And as we covered above, building replacement cost is up 43% while insurance has doubled: the rent required to justify new construction keeps rising. That’s the connection between this section and the last one. Operating and construction costs aren’t just a landlord complaint, they’re the floor under future rents.
The Landlord’s Moat: It’s Expensive to Move and Buy
Demand has a second tailwind, and it’s the buy-vs-rent gap. One 2026 analysis puts average rent at $1,669 against $2,589 in monthly costs for a starter home: buying costs about $920 more per month, roughly 55% more, than renting. (Yahoo Finance) With the 30-year at 6.81% after Jackson Hole, that gap isn’t closing this fall.
So renters renew. Retention is running near record levels, and Jay Parsons says he’d “take the over” on the consensus ~2% rent growth forecast for 2026 if job growth holds. (Multifamily Dive)

Source: Yahoo Finance 2026 rent-vs-buy analysis; gap calculated.
My Take: the rent bottom appears to be in. Not a boom: a steady grind up as the 2024–25 supply wave gets absorbed and the pipeline behind it empties out. For operators, the next 24 months may be the window where patient underwriting gets rewarded: buy at today’s soft rents, hold into tomorrow’s supply hole. This is the same setup we described in The Housing Market Is Frozen, Not Broken: the freeze creates the discount, the thaw creates the payoff.
The Steelman: Jobs Must Remain Robust
The bear case on rents is not weak, so let’s give it its due. 1)) Demand is hostage to jobs, and July payrolls fell by 23,000, with labor force participation at a five-year low of 61.4%. (BLS) If hiring stalls, household formation stalls, and the absorption story with it. 2)) The national average hides a split: rents are still falling outright across much of the Sun Belt and Mountain West, where the glut was concentrated. If your market is Austin or Phoenix, “the bottom is in” may be a 2027 sentence, not a 2026 one. 3)) Shadow supply is real: a record-adjacent 117,000 completed-but-unsold new homes are sitting on builder lots (Census), and some of that inventory leaks into the rental pool as builders and investors rent what they can’t sell. 4)) The supply cliff can partially refill itself: if rates drop meaningfully, some shelved projects restart, and 2028 deliveries surprise to the upside. The cliff is locked for ~24 months, not forever.
Questions I’d want answered before sizing up: how much of the retention record is renters trapped rather than satisfied (trapped renters churn hard the moment the buy-vs-rent gap narrows)? And how much of the Q1 starts collapse is genuine capitulation versus projects waiting on a rate cut to un-pause? The first has no clean data. The second we may learn by year-end.
Another Quick Break:
Try My FREE DealLab Real Estate Calculator!
Want help running numbers on your next deal (or an existing property you have)?
I built a free real estate deal analyzer: DealLab, the deal analyzer.
Run your next deal through it, kick the tires, and reply to this email with what’s missing, and what would make it indispensable for you and your business.

Quick Take: Nashville Is Hiring
Nashville’s metro unemployment rate sat at 3.3% in June, against a national rate of 4.1% in July. (FRED, Nashville MSA; BLS) The metro ranked #2 among America’s 100 largest for job growth and income (Capital Analytics), and Tennessee is projected to add about 31,400 jobs in 2026, nearly double the national growth rate. (UT Boyd Center)

Sources: FRED NASH947URN (June, not seasonally adjusted); BLS (July, seasonally adjusted).
In a month when national payrolls went negative, that spread is the whole story. Jobs are renters now and buyers later. It’s why Nashville is grinding out positive price growth while Tampa, Dallas and Phoenix go backwards.
Quick Deal Break
Update, Sept 2026: Hey readers — I'm actively looking for my next multifamily deal, and for deals for my clients. We just closed a 36-unit and a 20-unit for clients, and I'm hunting for more. If you're an investor looking for property, or you have a deal, shoot me an email or see what I'm buying. — Andreas Mueller, Keller Williams Music City Realty, 615-425-3600
A Quick Ad Break…Your Company Here!

Want to advertise to the more than 60,000 weekly readers of The Skeptical Investor? You can! Advertise with us; we can help you grow your business.
Ok, back to business.
My Skeptical Take
The financial commentary this week wants you anxious, hanging on every word from the Federal Reserve and Chair Warsh’s speech in Wyoming.
Don’t get caught in the noise.
Sure, the bond market wobbled, mortgage rates ticked up a tad, and the word “inflation” is everywhere in headlines.
Fine.
It’s starting to get a little weird again, and I’d rather look at what the weirdness is actually telling us.
Sticky inflation is a tax on everyone, but it is not neutral in who it taxes. It punishes the saver holding cash. It punishes the renter whose wages grow 3.2% while prices grow 3.7%. And it quietly rewards the owner of a hard asset financed with fixed-rate debt, whose replacement cost just rose 43%, whose competition just stopped building, and whose debt shrinks in real terms every year the numbers stay sticky.
Own assets. I choose real estate.
That’s the string running through this whole issue.
Operating costs exploded: that’s inflation. The $600 problem: that’s inflation meeting incomes.
The empty construction pipeline: that’s inflation meeting builder math.
The rent bottom: that’s what happens when new supply can’t pencil below today’s rents.
Each is the same story wearing a different hat.
To be clear, I’m not celebrating any of it. A third of renters priced out of the cost of housing, before profit, is a civic problem that private owners alone won’t solve, and we should say so plainly.
But as investors, our job is to see the board as it is. Scarce assets, rising replacement costs, durable demand, shrinking future supply: that’s as clean a setup as one can ask for. The patient operator who buys carefully into today’s soft market will spend 2028+ very happy they did.
In the words of Louis Glickman, the old New York real estate mogul:
“The best investment on earth is earth.”
— Louis Glickman, 1957
Until next time. Stay Curious. Stay Skeptical.
Herzliche Grüße,
P.S. Want to level up your real estate game?
You can consult with me, The Skeptical Investor! Get professional advice from someone who actually owns, operates, and brokers real estate.
Want to Grow? - Get clarity on how to grow your business or scale.
Stuck? - Get answers to your problem, let's hop on the phone and figure it out.
No "guru" trying to sell you an expensive course. No BS. No fluff. Only results.
I'll give you my frank, brutally honest advice. Book a call with me today.
It’s 2026. Be an owner.
Please Share this Article!
We have passed 60,000 subs! Thank you for your support, next stop, 70,000!
Please help grow the community!
It takes me several hours to write this weekly article, and they will always remain free (but you get some pretty cool perks with premium, including a one-on-one with yours truly :). All I ask is that you share it with 1 friend. Just 1. If you do, you will get two gifts: free education for one of your friends, and good karma for helping to grow a community of folks trying to figure out a way to create wealth for their family.
What, did you want, a cookie? 😅
Subscribe Today! (and get some amazing perks)
Paid subscribers get the best stuff! Subscribe to access:
Premium content and NO paywall,
Every article we have published - a treasure trove of information and education,
PLUS, a free one-on-one call with me personally to help you. A $500 value. So make sure to take advantage! Subscribe today.
Just $5 bucks a month.👇


